Elise (Amy Poehler) standing in an archeological site in Dig Season 1.
TV TV Reviews

Dig Review

When one thinks about network comedies of the early 2000s, it’s impossible not to think of Mike Schur, the showrunner, writer, and producer behind such stunners as Parks and Recreation, Brooklyn 99, and The Good Place. So, when word came out that Schur was planning to team-up with his Parks and Rec star Amy Poehler to bring a new comedy series to Peacock, well, I was thrilled. That Dig, a series set on a summer archeological dig in Greece, was set to focus on four women was also intriguing – and rarity in this age of comedies. Unfortunately, having seen the entire first season of the show, Dig turned out to be a stunted and messy series that desperately needed more time and more character development in order to get things right.

Now, this is the part of the review where I stress – as I always do when writing about a first season of a show that I think missed the mark – that first seasons are notoriously hard to do. For every The Good Place (which easily has one of the best first seasons of any television series ever), there’s a Parks and Rec, where even the biggest fans often advise people simply to skip the first season and jump into the second. First seasons are for figuring out what works, what doesn’t, which characters bounce well off one another, and who doesn’t fit within the world at all (sorry, Mark Brendanawicz). And, clocking in at 10 30-ish-minute episodes, there’s not a lot of time for Dig to do that work. Which means we get a number of truncated character arcs, characters with little to no development, and a story that feels way too rushed and only really starts to click in the final episodes. There are some good things within the series (which I’ll call out shortly), but if the season had been even 13 episodes long, I think it would have been stronger overall.

So, what is Dig? Elise (Poehler) is a curmudgeonly second-in-command on a Greek summer dig site, waiting for her boss Neville (Hugh Laurie, pretty good as the stuck-up peacock character) to finally retire so she can get her shot at leading the dig. She’s surrounded by a number of college, grad school, and professional helpers, but the three we care about are Clare (Antonia Thomas, best known for the great British series Misfits), the site preservationist, Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan, a scene-stealer from Thunderbolts*), who returns to the dig after disappearing without a word five years ago, and Patty (Fina Strazza), an awkward college kid who is there to be Neville’s assistant. Through a series of hi-jinks, Elise and Dylan discover a fully intact statue of Hera in one of the old dig sites (and Clare and Patty are read into the find as well), and decide to keep the discovery from Neville so that Elise can finally get some credit for her work. When the statue suddenly goes missing, the four must figure out who took it and try to get it back. So, a comedy mixed with a mystery with a host of potential suspects that we meet throughout the season.

The problem with the story is that there’s almost no room to breathe within it – and when we get the chance to spend time with our central characters without the machinations of the mystery threaded through it, we don’t learn more about them. We know that Elise has problems trusting people – she had a terrible divorce (which we are told several times, but don’t learn the details of) and Neville constantly tells her he’s retiring only to pull back at the last minute and stay on – but we don’t really get any clear resolution on that (or any sign, other than Elise telling us that she wants to get better at it, that she is, in fact, trying to get better at it). Dylan’s sole character trait is that she’s flighty and unreliable – which she remains until the end of the season (despite her claims to the contrary). Clare is . . . rich and British with an overbearing mother? I’m honestly not all that certain who she is beyond that. And then there’s Patty, the only character in the show with a clear arc, clear development, and who, for my money, will be the breakout star of the series.

I was primed not to like Patty as a character from the jump. With a squeaky voice, she’s clearly set up to be the character the audience cannot stand. She’s a people pleaser, is constantly screwing things up (Strazza is a master at physical comedy and nails every prat fall she is asked to do), and also desperately wants to be liked. But, by the end of the season, Patty was absolutely my favorite character. And much of that is thanks to Strazza’s performance. She’s just a spectacular actor, capturing the painful way Patty understands how the rest of the world sees and dismisses her, yet showing us how much Patty yearns for friendship and people she can confide in. Poehler, Thomas, and Viswanathan do their best work of the season when they’re working with Strazza, as Patty seems to bring out the more humane elements of all three characters. It’s the character of Patty that makes me believe that there’s the potential for a better show here than what we got in season one – and I would like to see what Schur and Poehler can pull off in a second season where other characters get the same complete arc that Patty gets here.

There are a host of guest and recurring characters (played by a host of familiar faces both from Schur’s other projects and from other comedies you know and love), and each pops but doesn’t get nearly enough to ultimately do. And that’s the main issue with the series: There’s not enough time to make us understand and fall in love with these characters – save for Patty. Dig isn’t a bad show, it’s not a poorly written or acted show. But it’s a show without complexity, a show that lacks emotional arcs, and a show that doesn’t have the time to utilize the cast it has at its disposal. I’m not mad that I watched it, but I had been hoping for a bit more. I do have hope that a second season (perhaps a slightly longer one) would be a bit stronger from the character standpoint.

The first season of Dig drops November 23 on Peacock. All ten episodes were provided for review.

  • Writing
  • Acting
  • Direction
3.2
Jean Henegan
Based in Chicago, Jean has been writing about television since 2012, for Entertainment Fuse and now Pop Culture Maniacs. She finds the best part of the gig to be discovering new and interesting shows to recommend to people (feel free to reach out to her via Twitter if you want some recs). When she's not writing about the latest and greatest in the TV world, Jean enjoys traveling, playing flag football, training for races, and watching her beloved Chicago sports teams kick some ass.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *