Christmas season is upon us, with one of the seasonal offerings being a new adaptation of A Christmas Carol, which is acting as Johnny Depp’s big comeback film.
Ebenezer Scrooge (Depp) is a greedy businessman who has a cynical view of Christmas and the poor. On Christmas Eve, Scrooge is warned by his old business partner (Ian McKellen) that he will be visited by three ghosts who set out to change his ways before it’s too late.
The online discourse around Ebenezer has been lively to say the least. It’s easy to go on social media and see posts saying they won’t watch it because of Johnny Depp and recent controversies surrounding him, and being produced by Paramount after Skydance’s takeover. The discourse around Depp has been divisive because of his high-profile divorce with Amber Heard and the subsequent civil suits. The worst thing to come out of the whole affair was Andy Signore being able to grift off the case for years and acting like he was the driving force behind the pro-Johnny movement.

The critical reaction to Ebenezer has been mixed, but the audience reaction has been more positive, and it topped the box office on its opening weekend. This outcome felt like the left-wing version of the ‘go woke, go broke’ mantra where people complaining online have little impact. There have been honest reviews from critics like Peter Bradshaw and Linda Marric, but others, such as David Ehrlich and Brandon Wu, went after Depp, saying he was at his worst. It was like when some critics reviewed Sound of Freedom and Flight Risk, where they focused on the people in front of and behind the camera rather than those films’ content. Depp was actually more restrained when playing the grumpy miser: it was far from his wacky performances in films like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and Alice in Wonderland. The makeup on Depp made him look like the 2009 version of Scrooge in live-action.
There has been a glut of A Christmas Carol adaptations over the past seven years. There has been a miniseries for the BBC and FX, a film in 2020, and three musical versions in the form of Scrooge: A Christmas Carol, Spirited and Christmas Karma. Two of those adaptations featured Andy Serkis. Ebenezer was a more traditional adaptation because of the Victorian setting, the title cards that use a vintage font, and the Danny Elfman-sounding score.

Ti West helmed Ebenezer. He’s an experienced horror director who is best known for the X trilogy. He brought that approach to Ebenezer and emphasised the horror aspects. The ghosts were tortured beings who wailed in pain. They were a warning to Scrooge because he could end up being like them. The Ghost of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough) looked like a corpse due to her skin being drained of colour, and her milky white eyes, whilst The Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) decayed in front of Scrooge. When Scrooge was confronted by Marley’s Ghost, he peed himself in terror. For anyone who wants a more horror-themed then Ebenezer fits the bill.
Online commentators have criticised Ebenezer for being pro-billionaire propaganda. They complained that the film sided with pre-redemption Scrooge due to him seeing a beggar faking a war wound, one of his old bosses being killed by a beggar, and charitable men were hypocrites and thieves. However, these criticisms were overblown because the film does show the hardships of poverty and the workhouse conditions were so horrible that people would do anything to avoid them. Belle (Ellie Bamber), a woman Ebenezer once loved, volunteered to help the poor and homeless, and it was portrayed as a noble act. Scrooge was criticised for his statement of ridding the world of the ‘surplus population.’ Ebenezer had more understanding of its source material than Emerald Fennell’s adaptation of Wuthering Heights.

The heart of every Christmas Carol adaptation is about Scrooge’s redemption. Despite Scrooge having a hard shell, deep down he did have some empathy. When he was shown the hardships of the poor and the hardships of Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint) and his family, he was concerned. It wasn’t just self-interest that drove Scrooge’s change of heart. He wasn’t like Elon Musk, Sam Altman, or Peter Thiel, who have unpalatable views about humanity and would have laughed at the plight of the poor.
Despite the controversy surrounding Ebenezer, it was not the Christmas turkey that its detractors wanted it to be. It was actually a perfectly serviceable adaptation of A Christmas Carol because it humanised Scrooge and was a chilling ghost story.





-
Direction
-
Writing
-
Acting




