The final season of Yellowjackets is both frustrating and entertaining – often at the exact same time. What started out as a really compelling story – what would happen if you dropped a bunch of teenage girls into the wilderness a la Lord of the Flies and then joined the survivors of that experience twenty-some years into the future (oh, and throw in some “there might be supernatural powers at work” signs for fun) – started spiraling out of control near the end of season two and fully lost its grip on reality in season three. It also didn’t help that the series killed off three of its adult versions of characters rather unceremoniously over the course of seasons two and three*, shrinking the adult side of the story, which meant those remaining characters ended up drawn increasingly broad in order to make that arc pop. But with only ten episodes remaining and a heck of a lot more story left to tell, this final season runs up against a lot of the same issues as past seasons, with the present arc swinging wildly in tone from moment to moment and a lack of real stakes in the (now) two past storylines making those story beats feel tired.
*While the killing off of adult Natalie was, reportedly, at the request of Juliette Lewis (who no longer wished to work on a television series), the loss of both adult Van (Lauren Ambrose) and adult Lottie (Simone Kessell) really reverberates throughout season four, both in terms of the limited stories available to tell and in some strangely executed story beats that suffer from the loss of both Ambrose and Kessell from the cast.
This time out, we have three competing timelines: the final days of the team in the wilderness awaiting rescue, the immediate aftermath of their return from the wilderness, and the present day arc. The final days in the wilderness is the least successful of the lot, mostly due to the fact the writers opt to drag it out over the course of the entire season. Since we more or less know what must happen here – a handful of remaining red shirt teammates needs to be disposed of along with Hannah (Ashley Sutton), the team needs to make it so that there’s no trace of what they did, and they must grapple with the wilderness once and for all (or so they think) – it’s less interesting as each moment gets ticked off the list. There aren’t any real stakes – which has been a refrain of mine with this arc for two seasons now – so trying to present this arc as if it has them cheapens the story being told. Similarly, the return to society lacks the stakes of the present day – especially since we know what happens to the characters thanks to conversations we’ve seen with their adult selves – but it’s still interesting to watch the characters attempt to acclimate back into a world that is so different than the one they just left. And it’s interesting to see where their friends and family are as well, since they all thought they had lost the team and must now grapple with their sudden return. The younger cast members do their best work in this segment the story, getting to take on new challenges and work with new actors. And since the team are separated at points in this part of the story, we get more time to see how they are slowly growing into who they will become as adults. Still, I’m not sure we needed the length of time the show spends within this arc, as it starts to feel reductive by mid-season.

Finally, there’s the adult present day timeline. And here’s where I think the season really goes off the rails. Much of this arc revolves around Shauna (Melanie Lynskey), now that we only have Melissa (a recurring Hilary Swank), Taissa (Tawney Cypress), and Misty (Christina Ricci) left out of the survivors, and all three of them want Shauna dead (or at least tormented). Add to the arc that Jeff (Walter Kole) and Callie (Sarah Desjardins) each have their own mini-arcs that involve Shauna and this part of the show is really is all about her. And, at times, it works great. Lynskey is a spectacular actor and has a real handle on Shauna. And there’s a scene between Tai, Shauna, and Misty, where the trio are smoking a joint and talking, honestly for once, that might have been my favorite moment out of all the episodes I’ve seen – it’s simple, smart, and funny without being over the top while also showing us the humanity that remains within these characters despite everything they have experienced and done. But to keep the story churning, we spend so much time watching characters plot against Shauna, see the repercussions of that plotting, and then watch Shauna respond. And then each of our main characters gets their own strange side quest that doesn’t do much for the overall story and barely moves the needle for their character development – which, at this stage of the game, isn’t really needed. The Tai side quest, in particular, is such a retread of ground we’ve already walked with her that I actually felt annoyed for both the character and Cypress for having to go through it all again.
Yellowjackets had a pretty straightforward premise at the outset, with a mystery of how the teens survived – was it luck, skill, or supernatural aid – and one surrounding if their actions in the past would be revealed in the future. Now, at the end of things, that first question will be answered, but that second one? Well, that one seems to have morphed into “Will they all survive in the present and if not, who kills whom?” And that switch in focus from “Will the truth come out?” to “Will they make it out alive?” cheapens a lot of the story being told. Because the secret of what happened in the wilderness is one they have held close for decades – even when they can’t stand each other, they still haven’t told what they did. Wondering who might kill whom and if there’s a mystical spirit still plaguing them (easily the least interesting portion of the show – supernatural stories can only end in two ways and neither one is ever really satisfying) doesn’t excite me – although Shauna does some things this season that make one start to root against her. Unfortunately, the focus of the story has shifted to the wrong beats, leaving characters to act out of character throughout the season (seriously, there are some choices made that made me truly wonder if characters had lost their mind because past versions of them would never do that, only for the character to start acting perfectly on par with past actions moments later) and offering some wild tonal shifts that don’t always work.
I have only seen eight of the ten episodes, so it’s possible that things manage to wrap up nicely in the end – although about episode six, I wondered if there were more than ten episodes because there was so much story left. But I’m disappointed that the series wasn’t able to pull back on some of its more out there notions to give us a clean, concise, well-written story this time out. There’s some good stuff here – mostly in the performances, which remain pretty great across the board – but there’s also a lot of frustrating storytelling.
Yellowjackets’ fourth and final season begins airing on Showtime on Paramount+ on November 20th. Eight of the ten episodes were provided for review.
-
Writing
-
Acting
-
Direction




